Universal Basic Income (UBI) in India

Introduction

Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a proposed social welfare initiative that envisions providing a regular, unconditional cash payment to all citizens, regardless of their income, employment status, or any other criteria. In the Indian context, this concept has gained traction as a potential tool to address widespread poverty and economic inequality. UBI represents a radical shift in the way social justice and economic support are conceived, focusing on the principles of universality, unconditionality, and basic financial security.

Key Aspects of UBI in India

1. Unconditional Cash Transfer: The fundamental principle of UBI is that the payments are made without any conditions. Unlike traditional welfare programs, which often require recipients to meet specific eligibility criteria such as income thresholds or employment status, UBI provides financial support without any strings attached. This approach aims to simplify the distribution of benefits and reduce administrative burdens.

2. Universality: The ideal model of UBI proposes that payments should be made to all citizens, ensuring that no one is left out of the social safety net. However, there may be considerations to exclude the wealthiest individuals from receiving UBI to better allocate resources. The goal is to create an inclusive system that addresses the needs of the entire population, especially the marginalized and economically disadvantaged.

3. Potential Benefits:

   • Reduction in Poverty: UBI could provide a consistent source of income, helping to lift millions of Indians above the poverty line. By guaranteeing a minimum income, it could significantly improve the standard of living for many, providing them with the means to afford basic necessities.
   • Economic Stimulation: An increase in disposable income for a large portion of the population could lead to higher spending on goods and services, thereby boosting economic activity and potentially leading to job creation.
   • Empowerment: UBI can offer individuals greater financial independence, allowing them to make choices that improve their quality of life. This could include pursuing education, starting businesses, or taking care of family members without the constant pressure of financial insecurity.

The Concept of UBI

UBI is not just an economic measure; it represents a significant paradigm shift in how social justice and economic systems are conceptualized. The idea is to provide every member of society with a guaranteed minimum income, thus ensuring that everyone has access to basic goods and a dignified life. This concept parallels the importance of civil and political rights, which were central to the twentieth century. In this way, UBI could be considered a fundamental right that provides a foundation for individual well-being and societal stability.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Potential Benefits:

1. Poverty Reduction: With a significant portion of India's population living below the poverty line, UBI could provide a crucial financial floor, lifting many out of poverty. For instance, a study by the Institute for Policy Research in Chicago highlighted a UBI pilot in Kenya, which resulted in notable reductions in poverty and hunger.

2. Economic Boost: By increasing the purchasing power of citizens, UBI can stimulate demand for goods and services, leading to increased production and potentially higher employment rates. A pilot program in Finland showed a slight increase in employment among recipients, suggesting positive economic impacts.

3. Increased Social Mobility: UBI can act as a safety net, allowing individuals to take entrepreneurial risks, pursue higher education, or engage in other activities that can improve their social and economic status. In Stockton, California, a UBI pilot found that recipients were more likely to start businesses or continue their education.

4. Improved Well-being: Financial security can reduce stress and anxiety, leading to better overall health outcomes. For example, studies in Finland indicated a reduction in depressive symptoms among UBI recipients.

5. Gender Equality: UBI could provide women with greater financial independence, especially in patriarchal societies like India. Studies in various developing countries have shown that women often spend their UBI payments on essential household needs, benefiting entire families.

Drawbacks and Challenges:

1. Fiscal Sustainability: Implementing UBI in a country as large and diverse as India would require substantial financial resources. Identifying sustainable funding sources, such as taxation or reallocation of existing subsidies, poses a significant challenge.

2. Targeting vs. Universality: While a universal approach is ideal, it may not be financially feasible. An alternative is to target UBI to specific groups, such as the poor, unemployed, or elderly. However, this raises concerns about the fairness and efficiency of beneficiary selection.

3. Work Disincentive: Critics argue that UBI could reduce the incentive to work if basic needs are met without employment. However, evidence from various pilot programs is mixed, with some showing minimal impact on work hours.

4. Administrative Complexity: Disbursing UBI to a vast and diverse population would require a highly efficient and transparent administrative system to prevent leakages and ensure accurate delivery.

5. Inflationary Concerns: A significant increase in money supply through UBI could lead to inflation, potentially eroding the purchasing power of the poorest. Careful economic planning and modeling are necessary to address this risk.

Considerations for Implementation

• Funding: The Indian government could explore various funding sources, including reducing existing subsidies, implementing a wealth tax, or introducing a basic income tax. The financial viability of UBI will depend on the efficient use of these resources.

• Targeting: A phased approach to UBI implementation could be considered, starting with the most vulnerable populations and expanding coverage as economic conditions permit.

• Work Incentives: UBI can be integrated with existing workfare programs to encourage labor force participation. This could help balance the need for financial support with the encouragement of productive work.

Conclusion

The concept of Universal Basic Income presents a complex yet promising policy option for India. While the potential benefits in terms of poverty reduction, economic growth, and social mobility are significant, careful consideration must be given to the fiscal and administrative challenges. Further research, pilot programs, and public discourse are essential to determine the feasibility and design of a UBI system that can effectively address poverty and inequality while promoting economic growth and social well-being in the Indian context.

Citations

1. Universal basic income. (n.d.). Drishti IAS. Retrieved from Drishti IAS.
2. GeeksforGeeks. (2022, October 17). Universal Basic Income: Its advantages and concerns. Retrieved from GeeksforGeeks
3. MicroSave Consulting (MSC). (2024, March 19). Universal Basic Income: A policy option for India? Retrieved from MicroSave Consulting

"Unlock the Potential of Legal Expertise with LegalMantra.net - Your Trusted Legal Consultancy Partner”

Article Compiled by:-

~Sura Anjana Srimayi

(LegalMantra.net Team)

Disclaimer: Every effort has been made to avoid errors or omissions in this material in spite of this, errors may creep in. Any mistake, error or discrepancy noted may be brought to our notice which shall be taken care of in the next edition In no event the author shall be liable for any direct indirect, special or incidental damage resulting from or arising out of or in connection with the use of this information Many sources have been considered including Newspapers, Journals, Bare Acts, Case Materials , Charted Secretary, Research Papers etc.