22 Nov 2026

Hindustan Foods Ltd. v. BSE & SEBI

Hindustan Foods Ltd. v. BSE & SEBI

Settled with SEBI? The Exchange Can Still Fine You.

SAT, Mumbai — Hindustan Foods Ltd. v. BSE & SEBI (Appeal No. 178 of 2024), decided 13.08.2026

A settlement order is not a closure certificate. That is the short lesson from a ruling the Securities Appellate Tribunal delivered last week.

The facts, briefly

Hindustan Foods fell short of Regulation 17(1)(b) of the LODR Regulations — at least half its eight-member board had to comprise independent directors — for various periods between August 2018 and November 2022. The company applied to SEBI for settlement, and a settlement order followed in October 2023 on payment of ?24.32 lakh.

BSE then imposed an SOP fine of ?52,21,500 for the very same breach. The company paid under protest and appealed, on a single ground: res judicata and double jeopardy.

What the Tribunal held

The appeal was dismissed, and the reasoning is worth noting for three converging reasons:

Regulation 98 of LODR says a contravening entity shall be liable to exchange action — including fines - in addition to liability under securities laws. The Tribunal underlined those words.

Clause 7 of SEBI's circular dated 22.01.2020 preserves SEBI's power to act under securities laws notwithstanding exchange action.

The settlement order itself carried an express clause stating it was without prejudice to action by recognised stock exchanges under that circular.

Following its own decision in Alien Developers Pvt. Ltd. (15.10.2025), the Bench reiterated that regulatory compliance before BSE and before SEBI operate in different spheres — so the double jeopardy plea was without merit.

Why this matters for listed companies

  • Read the carve-outs. The clause that decided this appeal was sitting in the settlement order the company had accepted. Settlement terms define the immunity; they do not imply more than they say.

 

  • Budget for both. The exchange fine here exceeded the settlement amount by more than double. Treating settlement as the total cost of a lapse can understate exposure significantly.

 

  • Cure early. SOP fines accrue per day of default. A four-year board composition gap is expensive arithmetic.

 

  • Two forums, two questions. SEBI settlement addresses SEBI's proceedings. It does not answer for exchange-level SOP consequences.

 

For boards and compliance teams, the practical takeaway is unglamorous but useful: closing one file does not close the other.

 

DISCLAIMER: THE CONTENTS OF THIS DOCUMENT ARE PROVIDED BASED ON CURRENT PROVISIONS AND INFORMATION AVAILABLE. WHILE EVERY EFFORT HAS BEEN MADE TO ENSURE ACCURACY AND RELIABILITY, NO RESPONSIBILITY IS ASSUMED FOR ANY ERRORS OR OMISSIONS. USERS ARE ENCOURAGED TO REFER TO APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATIONS. THIS INFORMATION IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS LEGAL ADVICE, AND NO LIABILITY IS ACCEPTED FOR ANY CONSEQUENCES ARISING FROM ITS USE.

From the desk of CS Sharath